Re: What games are you currently playing?
Guild Wars 2 is a platformer? That's news to me.
I'm still failing to see how not allowing a vastly simpler alternate route (by design or otherwise) is a mistake in design. That section is clearly set up for the complex path to the right. It's not hidden at all; there's a whole sequence of similar but slightly simpler platforms before that section to get you used to the idea. The fact that it might look like you can take the easy way out doesn't mean squat because the game does not ever imply that this is what you ought to be doing. The first time you fail at doing it should be enough of a warning to tell you to reevaluate your approach. Instead, BBQ instantly assumed - incorrectly - that there were invisible walls because his not-so-clever almost-cheat didn't work and didn't want to do it the obvious way.
Is that the fault of the designer, or is that faulty logic on the part of the player? I hold that it's the latter, not the former.
Icemage
Originally posted by Yellow Mage
View Post
Also, your edit doesn't address BBQ's point that the platform is a mistake in design that, apparently, got a ham-fisted remedy. I don't see how you're not seeing what's wrong with that.
Is that the fault of the designer, or is that faulty logic on the part of the player? I hold that it's the latter, not the former.
Icemage
Comment