Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

[Ryddr]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

8 of 10

Your uh...w..wy...wyvern is um...growing...or something...








P.S. May wanna hit up the vet

[Hustler_One]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

8/10

Because I like the comment. XD

[Stromgarde]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

Decent enough, if you don't mind the weapon/armor mismatch on an apparently unrelated background.

My sig rotates, click it to see all of them.

[Humar]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

Original, but short, and if it's an inside joke, I don't get it... 3/10

Well if it was an inside joke of course you wouldnt get it but no its not i just didnt know what to put.....and while pics are nice i like ones that just have words

and ill rate the previuse one too..(metal paladin solid)its awesome ill give it 9/10

[Mog]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

10/10, just because mithra pie is the best!

[Taskmage]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

-8/10 because the moogles playing cards are gone, and you changing your name AND sig at the same time made me not know who you were for like two months.

[Feba]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

Nice sig, but you could do without the flavor text. Imo, it's just dirtying it up.

[greydaze]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

Not sure what it has to do with FFXI, but it's nicely drawn, and I like the colours. Relaxing, but not boring.

It doesn't have to be FFXI-related. <.< My entire life isn't just FFXI.

And about the sig... It's a bit dark. Might want to lighten it a bit; it's hard to see the blm. 7/10

[Feba]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

it's meant to be dark, it's an ingame photo :p

[greydaze]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

You can still edit it, just as you did to size it.

[Feba]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

That was just cropping. Other than that, there's been no modification to the photo

[Taskmage]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

Nice sig, but you could do without the flavor text. Imo, it's just dirtying it up.

Mm, you're not the first person to say that, but for me the image is there to make the words look pretty. I love words in a Jerry Holkins kind of way. The Ghost in the Shell quote ties in nicely to the theme of my new favorite job's flag quest, losing something precious and unspoken to move forward, and has special signifigance to the stagnation that is my life's crisis right now. Having made that overly detailed explanation, I think I'll keep the text. ^^ Compared to some of the passages I wish I could use for sigs, this is terse. But, I won't fault your taste if you find this to be a prettier picture:


Feba's sig: I wish I knew where the heck that was, but the lighting and composition of the shot give really strong mood and tension. Your arbitrary score is 8 with a +1 bonus for simplicity.

greydaze's sig: I've always been lukewarm on Ah Megamisama, but the presentation is attractive. Your arbitrary score is 6. ^^

[Stromgarde]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

Feba: I like it better darker, personally; It fits the location.
9/10 technical
10/10 inspiration
+1 for Incredible Discovery.

Greydaze: ...I have somewhat of a soft spot for A!MGS. The pictures are well-blended, though the one on the left seems to be of somewhat different style than the other two.
7/10 technical
7/10 inspiration

Taskmage: Yours is well done as usual. I think that it could possibly benefit from blurring of the Ayeedawa scene in the background to enhance the illusion of focus in the foreground, however.

7/10 technical
9/10 inspiration

And my complete collection follows, since I don't want to be destroying my own bandwidth by way of forcing F-5 mashing.

40%

40%

10%

5%

5%

Not currently in use

[Taskmage]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

Good thought. Here's a tweaked version with a small blur on the BG. The composition that was left when I just yanked the text out bugged me. Looked like it wanted to fall over.



I'll come up with something actually new to comment on soon. I'm wanting to change to match my new title.

Edit: Your unused FF4 reference scores a win/10 ^^d

[Stromgarde]

Re: Rate The person sig's above you v2.0

Most excellent. Thoughts on mine? (see above)

Edit: Burned by the edit button. Curses!