WAR vs DRK

[MeleeFighterFF]

yup...notice nothing but replies from defensive wars...

i love it...

and im so sick of hearing this crap about no matter what lvl someone is they're LOW ...36? you dont think at 36, and where my other jobs are, with months into the game, i know what the jobs are for?

maybe you didnt but hey you're the guy who thinks war/nin is the highest dmg dealer in the game.

obviously my intelligence gives me a push in the right direction, where yours flushes the toilet for ya.

also...do u think im OBLIVIOUS to what other ppl say...ive spoke to so many ppl 70+ it's not even worth counting...actually about this specific issue...when i was a 20 something war i didnt know what route to go with things...

they all said "you want to tank with war at high lvls sub nin for blink tanking"....

tell me what ninja abilities give u this uber dmg dealing ability over EVERY other melee that was designed to do the job?

[Guile]

hey you're the guy who thinks war/nin is the highest dmg dealer in the game.

Um, you obviously cannot read.... no one said that.

[Ozymandis]

Originally posted by MeleeFighterFF
War/nin can do some dmg...but a party is never going to ask the war/nin to berserk and dmg deal simply because of the fact that there's several other job combos that are going to put it to shame dmg wise...drg/war, sam/war, mnk/war, war/thf, thf/war, thf/nin, drk/war, rng/war etc,...they all deal literally 3-5 times the dmg a war/nin does in the course of an exp partie's night...it's not even remotely close.

LOL! You should be slapped for saying this. DRG and SAM outdamaging well-equipped WAR/NIN? When and where and how? Not often, for sure, if ever.

RNG? Yes, if he's not a total gimp.
DRK? Maybe but not for a long while because of lack of good WSes early.
MNK? Maybe, depends on skillchain and equipment.

I doubt you will find many DRGs and SAMs who will make the claim that you did.

[Meimei]

At my lvl a drk do 130-160 damage, a war/nin hit 70-100 damage per hit, and they hit 2 times per swing, and they double attack 1/3 times and they have much higher acc. And hell war/nin can even steal aggro from pld easy with berserk + aggressor. The only reason drk own war in dmg is their spinning slash and cross reaper owns with thf sub they can do 900 damage + 1300 light/darkness

_______________

Warrior 75
Thief 37
Ninja 37
Samurai 37 <retired>
Monk 15
http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?17309
http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?17313

[MeleeFighterFF]

oh stop ...

im so sick of tarus that have never touched a dmg dealing role dropping in there two cents...


i have already searched high and low...other than this forum, the only response ive ever gotten was a hysterical laugh about saying war/nin is the highest dmg dealer in the game....

it's not dude...and i already said to stop pulling this shit about "if one's better equipped than the other..." out of your ass >>>BLAH

assuming u were to take a war/thf, drk/thf, drk/war , mnk/war and war/nin all at lvl 75 with the best equip on possible...explain to me what you're going to do with your ninja that's going to outdamage a mnk or drk?

where does this come from? your abilities are designed for blink tanking...where do u get all of this damage dealing from?

p.s. i nor several of the other people im talking to right now (some in the 60's) have ever seen a war/nin do anything other than tank.

[Bigokk McGock]

You're LS buddies are having a good 'ol chuckle in Valkum eh?

Where is the post that says War/Nin is the best damage dealer in the game? You're not going to find that one, because no one posted that, boy.

I'm starting to doubt you're even level 36.

The funniest thing about this troll is that he refuses to acknowledge my parsed logs.

The first indication of a troll is that he totally avoids logical responses and hard facts. That fits him to the T.

[MeleeFighterFF]

The only reason drk own war in dmg is their spinning slash and cross reaper owns with thf sub they can do 900 damage + 1300 light/darkness

uhhh....the only reason drk owns war in dmg?

isnt that still a reason? moron...heh

thank you for just confirming that a drk does outdamage a war...

also...havent you guys ever heard the thousands upon thousands of ex wars who played both that and mnk say "mnk is such a better melee"...

im just another one of them...how are u going to outdamage a mnk with your war? explain that to someone...cause like i said, im not getting anything but a laugh out of people in game

[neighbortaru]

/psst let's not embarass him. I don't think he can read.

edit: ok, it's official, he can't.

[MeleeFighterFF]

i saw your parsers...i guess i didnt make it clear enough to you that i think they're BS just like you think im BS...

the results you came up with are so unique that no other parser ever shown has come up with those results...

and calling me boy and saying im in valkurm...oh yeah that's brilliant...

boy ...lol like you're some kind of gay child molester who's jonesin or something

[Guile]

By the way I am no Taru..... i've taken drk to 30 and war to 30.... Im elvaan. Just incase Melees post was focused towards me.

[MeleeFighterFF]

again instead of kissing each other's asses why not discuss this where i told u the discussion is going on now...


there's 3 of you here who have a war high lvl and think it's the best...you're ignorant to what anyone else believes...fix that for yourself and go tell 1000 ppl that war/nin delivers the highest melee dmg in the game, and is right on a rangers ass and then see how many of them go ballistic and tell you how fuckin dumb you and war both are.

[Bigokk McGock]

Post damage logs to prove your boasts, if not, you lose this argument. (You lost already)

[MeleeFighterFF]

i lost nothing LOL

this is classic...

4th time...discuss this in front of ppl other than wars...

you basically said earlier the reason nobody knows that war/nin does this kind of dmg is for the same reason they think mnk is gimp too (which that's a newsflash...everyone knows what a mnk does) ...because basically they dont know any better

why is it that only you higher lvl wars know these amazing secrets to the job class that makes it superior in tanking and dmg dealing to everything?

btw...u said what makes war/nin is good is that it can dmg deal or tank

i argued that weeks ago and all i got was FLAMED by ppl saying "nobody needs a job that does 2 things well, they want a job in their party that does one thing, the best"

why would the party need u to tank if they have a pld?

why would they need u to dmg deal if they had rngers, mnks, or drk's? (drg, sam included heh...thf too)

they dont, you're just inventing ways to justify how war does everything the best...

[Guile]

I'm sorry but am I the only one finding melees posts absolutely hysterical?

You won't just give up will you? I'm beginning to think that you just want attention; because I don't think anyone could be as dumb as you.

[Bigokk McGock]

My parsed logs were so unique that they cannot be recreated...what?? R O F L

Yeah, only about 20 people of various same-higher level and hours upon hours of damage logs...that's so unique! L O L

Seriously, I don't blame you for being low level and naive, but when you gain a few levels and leave Qufim, you'll see just how wrong you are.

there's 3 of you here who have a war high lvl and think it's the best...you're ignorant to what anyone else believes...fix that for yourself and go tell 1000 ppl that war/nin delivers the highest melee dmg in the game

Again, show me where anyone said that warriors were the "highest melee dmg in the game".

If you even can show me a post by a high level warrior who said this, you win this entire argument.

Again, if not, you lose.