Over three years later...

[Patchinko]

( http://www.ffxionline.com/forums/red...t=Hornetneedle )


After more than three years and hundreds of bees... I have a superfast dagger! I know it might not be a big deal to a lot of people, but for me, this is huge. Finally, I can replace my Royal Guard's Fleuret.


Thanks to Omni for helping me farm for about an hour and a half tonight. Time to skill up!

[Armando]

Re: Over three years later...

Congratulations.

Although, I don't think replacing Royal Guard's Fleuret for a Hornetneedle is a good idea.

[Patchinko]

Re: Over three years later...

Congratulations.
Although, I don't think replacing Royal Guard's Fleuret for a Hornetneedle is a good idea.

For elemental farming, I believe it will be.

And of course for the massive skill-up I need to do since my Daggers is only at 60.

I will be keeping my RGF around, in reality! Like most things in this game, specific gear for specific purposes.
------------------------------------------
Oh yeah, and...

http://www.ffxiah.com/item.php?id=13290&sid=31

Cheap!

Ice Elementals here I come.

[Sabaron]

Re: Over three years later...

Every time I whip out my Fencer's Ring, someone cures me. I've really only been able to use it solo.

Without Fencer's:
Hornetneedle w/ Enspell: (16+17)/150 *60= 13.2DPS
Misericorde w/ Enspell: (27+17)/183 *60= 14.4DPS

With Fencer's:
Hornetneedle w/ Enspell: (16+17+5)/150 *60= 15.2DPS
Misericorde w/ Enspell: (27+17+5)/183 *60= 16.1DPS

With Hollow Earring too:
Hornetneedle w/ Enspell: (16+17+5+3)/150 *60= 16.4DPS
Misericorde w/ Enspell: (27+17+5+3)/183 *60= 17.0DPS

Misericorde always beats the needle. I love needle for skillup and capped stuff though.

To make Hornetneedle viable, you have to boost Enspell damage very high:

(16+17+5+3+x)/150 = (27+17+5+3+x)/183

(41 + x)/150 = (52 + x)/183

41/150 + x/150 = 52/183 + x/183
x/150 - x/183 = 52/183 + 42/150 {*150}
x - 150x/183 = 52*150/183 + 42 {*183}
183x - 150x = 52*150 + 42*183
33x = 7800 + 7686
33x = 15486
x = 15486/33

x = 469

Hmmm...Either my math is wrong (Check it!) or it's virtually impossible for Hornetneedle to be better than Misericorde.

[Patchinko]

Re: Over three years later...

Every time I whip out my Fencer's Ring, someone cures me. I've really only been able to use it solo.

...

Hmmm...Either my math is wrong (Check it!) or it's virtually impossible for Hornetneedle to be better than Misericorde.

Actually, if you check the thread I linked, Grendal did that test in-game!

Misericorde is indeed better.

But then again, it's level 71 and Hornetneedle is level 49, so it ought to be better.

And, that said, I'm level 66, so I won't be able to use a Misericorde for a while yet.

As for the Fencer's Ring, my intent is to use it solo to speed up Elemental (and other types of) farming. I would personally let myself get below 75% health, then Phalanx/SS to avoid taking more damage as opposed to healing up.

Being able to tear through Ice Elementals specifically is important because of how they have a limited time spawn during weather.